Baptismal Exorcism in the Lutheran Reformation: Three Defenses of the Received Rite

Repristination Press

Baptismal Exorcism in the Lutheran Reformation: Three Defenses of the Received Rite

Three newly translated sixteenth-century Lutheran defenses. Includes introductions, annotations, glossaries, and bibliographies.

Could a few words spoken before Baptism become a test of doctrine, church order, and confessional identity? In the later Lutheran Reformation, the inherited baptismal exorcism was acknowledged to be neither the substance of the Sacrament nor a command of Scripture. Yet its retention or abolition could divide pastors, alarm congregations, and signal a church’s movement toward or away from the Reformed confession.

This volume presents in English the three principal defenses gathered in a single 1590 German collection. Justus Menius addresses the Gotha controversy and the authority of the Church’s public order. Tilemann Heshusius distinguishes lawful omission in principle from disruptive private innovation, while grounding the rite in original sin, baptismal regeneration, and deliverance from the kingdom of darkness. Philip Melanchthon counsels doctrinal clarity, ceremonial latitude, and ecclesiastical peace. Jacobus Colerus brings the mature defense together through Scripture, philology, patristic testimony, church orders, and pastoral argument.

The writers repeatedly deny that exorcism makes Baptism valid or possesses an independent magical power. Their dispute concerns what the ceremony confesses, who may alter a received rite, and how an indifferent practice can acquire confessional weight when attacked for doctrinal reasons. A substantial general introduction also places these defenses in conversation with Aegidius Hunnius’s later Lutheran case for repealing the rite.

Translated from the 1590 Hartmann collection preserved at the Concordia Historical Institute, this edition includes historical introductions, translated title and prefatory materials, explanatory notes, reader’s guides, glossaries, source guides, and select bibliographies. It offers a documented primary-source study of Baptism, original sin, adiaphora, liturgical authority, and Lutheran–Reformed controversy in the sixteenth century.

Available editions

Amazon links are affiliate links. Repristination Press may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

Purchases are completed securely on Amazon. Current availability and pricing are shown there and may vary by marketplace.